Current Menu

PIES

PRICING

  • Full-Size (Serves 8-10): $27/each
  • Cutie Pies (Individual size – serves 1-2): $8/1 or $15/2
  • For custom pie designs, please contact emily@bakeeffect.com.
  • Select flavors can be made without dairy and egg for an additional fee.

Flavors

Hand-cut, tart-sweet apples combined with all the best warm spices and coupled with an apple cider reduction for maximum flavor. This is the appley-est apple pie you’ve ever had!

A hint of cinnamon and a dash of fresh lemon juice makes this combo of blackberries, raspberries, and blueberries a favorite at any time of year.

You’ve got to love a good crumble topping, and the light lemony zing of this one perfectly enhances the flavorful blueberry filling underneath.

Another fantastic combination of contrasting flavors that somehow just works. Bright raspberries meet the sweetness of peaches and perfectly balance each other. Topped with mini “jelly rolls” made from pie crust and homemade raspberry jam, it will quickly become your new favorite!

A classic flavor – kicked up a notch. Almond extract and warm spices temper the sourness of the cherries and add an unexpected (but delicious) dimension.

I know what you’re thinking…basil? In a PIE? Trust me on this one – with juicy strawberries and a lift provided by the basil and a pinch of lemon zest, it’s like bright, sunny weather in pie form. It’s my best seller for a reason!

That classic combo of strawberries and the weirdest vegetable ever (a.k.a. rhubarb), kicked up a notch with brown sugar and a hint of citrus. It’s the tart-sweet pie of your dreams!

A unique but delicious mix of flavors, this pie features the sweetness of dried figs and the tart punch of fresh cranberries, rounded out with a splash of orange juice.

Imagine mulled wine (without the wine!) in pie form. Dark sweet cherries, cloves, chocolate crust, and a secret ingredient make this a delicious winter pie unlike any other!

Unlike many pecan pies, this classic skips the corn syrup. Instead, a combo of granulated and brown sugars combine to create a perfectly balanced molasses-y, nutty filling.

Fresh pears are smothered in scratch-made spiced caramel, topped with a candied ginger crumble, then baked to golden perfection.






















SHORTIES

PRICING

  • One Dozen – $24
  • Mix-and-match Dozen (choose up to 4 flavors) – $24

Flavors

A classic flavor elevated by a sprinkle of flaky sea salt and a crispy turbinado sugar edge – a perfect combo of flavors and textures!

A one-of-a-kind fan favorite! Crushed kettle chips are baked right in AND sprinkled on top of this cookie’s honey-butter glaze. A secret ingredient adds to the salty-sweet perfection!

Dark cocoa powder: Check
Dark chocolate chips: Check
Cacao nibs: Check
Dark chocolate-dipped edge: Check

A rich, buttery cookie base studded with buttery toffee bits, then dipped in dark chocolate and topped with more toffee bits for an elegant finish.

Lemon zest and freeze-dried strawberries are baked throughout these summertime treats. A lemony glaze on the outside of the cookies kicks the sunshine factor up to 11!

As with the Strawberry Basil Pie, the herb provides a fresh boost to the bright, lemon-y flavor of this buttery cookie.  

Toasted coconut adds a delightful dimension, while sunny citrus juice and zest keeps the flavors bright. It’s summer in a cookie!

Earl Grey, meet Chai. Chai, meet Earl Grey. Bergamot oil and a homemade chai spice mix combine for a cozy cold-weather flavor. this buttery cookie studded throughout with freeze-dried strawberries.

Toasty browned butter is the perfect complement to the light and dark brown sugars in this cookie. A kick of saigon cinnamon adds dimension while tying everything together!

Pecan pieces are mixed in to this maple sugar-sweetened shortbread, which is then topped with more maple and more pecans!

This cookie knows what it’s about.

ROLL CAKES

PRICING

  • One Roll (serves 8-10): $24

Flavors

Luscious and chocolatey, this cake is an elevated version of the classic swiss roll. Rolled with a perfectly-sweet cream cheese filling and topped with a rich ganache and dark chocolate shavings, it’s a decadent treat for the chocolate lovers in your life!

Lemon lovers rejoice! Moist, lemon cake is wrapped delicately around a cream cheese and lemon curd filling, then topped with a light lemony glaze. Neither the sweetness nor the tart citrus overpowers this perfectly balanced dessert.

Cream cheese, pumpkin, and only the best spices come together to make a deliciously moist cake – the perfect way to get into the fall/winter spirit!

Sweet molasses and spicy ginger combine with a warm spice mix to make a delightfully complex swirl of goodness.

Is there a more classic winter flavor combination? Bits of peppermint candies are swirled into the cream cheese filling and sprinkled on top of a rich chocolate ganache drizzle.